When to Replace Gutters Instead of Repairing Them
Updated
Short answer
Replace when most seams leak, most runs sag, sections are split or rusted through, or the gutters are undersized for the roof. Repairs average $100 to $450; full replacement runs $2,200 to $5,000 (HomeGuide), and seamless aluminum $6 to $12 per foot.
Repair if
- The trouble is a few hangers, one or two seams, or one sagging run.
- The gutters are seamless aluminum in decent shape.
Replace if
- Leaks at many seams on old sectional gutters.
- Splits, holes or rust through steel gutters.
- Repeated overflow in heavy rain even when clean.
- The fascia needs replacing anyway.
Replacing sections runs $6 to $17 per foot. Replacement work over $1,000 needs a written contract under Illinois' Home Repair and Remodeling Act. See seamless gutter replacement.
Quick answers
How long do gutters last?
It depends on the material and upkeep. Angi notes seamed gutters have a shorter life span than seamless ones.
Rather have someone else do it?
Tell us the address, how tall the house is and what you need. A local crew calls back with a price before anything is booked.